Welcome to Pennywise!
Our inventory changes daily! Stop on in!

Pennywise Consignments Overstocks

Go Green This Summer!!
Recycle and Reuse Clothes, Shoes, Jewelry.

Fashionable Women's and Men's clothing, shoes, jewelry and accessories at affordable prices. The store sells new overstocks and returns from upscale stores. Consigned clothes are mixed in for a constantly changing variety of items.

The secret to Pennywise's success is that the store is a cut above all thrift and consignment stores. It is the oldest clothes store in Mystic, Ct. and sits across from the Mystic Seaport on Greenmanville Avenue (Route 27).

We also have a children's store, Just Kidding, in Downtown Mystic! Please bring your family in for a visit!

Designer purse
We've got a wide selection of designer purses in stock!

Steve's Pick of the Week!
Pennywise Steve


Find us on Facebook to keep up on all of the latest sales & deals!


Note: Above requires Flash 9 to view
We can also be found on Twitter!

Store Hours:
Mon-Sat 9:30-5:00
Sun 11:00-5:00
Consignments are accepted:
Mon-Fri 9:30-4:00.